DadCooksDinner Newsletter - November 2026Thanksgiving CountdownCooking for a Thanksgiving-sized crowd is a LOT different from cooking for, say, a dinner party with friends. Cooking for seven friends* is relaxing, a chance to get creative and show off, and to sip a glass of wine while chatting in the kitchen as you make dinner. *Hello to our monthly wine dinner group - Brian, Dave, Diane, Jackie, me, Pam, and Rhonda - hi guys! Cooking for Thanksgiving is completely different. Most home kitchens aren’t designed for this large of a meal, especially for a celebration meal like Thanksgiving, with all its “must have” side dishes. If the turkey is filling the oven, when can we cook the stuffing? How do we fit the gravy, mashed potatoes, green beans, and cranberry sauce on the stovetop at the same time? Making food for (in my case) 17 people* is more about logistics than cooking. *At least, I think it’s 17 people this year. That’s always part of the fun - planning for the “who’s coming this year” variable. This year is between 12 and 23 people. It depends on what cousins are in town, who wants to bring the in-laws, and if any boyfriends or girlfriends (or just friends) are joining us. I always try to cook extra, just in case we have extra guests - not just because I love Thanksgiving leftovers. The two keys are:
The PlanFor the plan, I list everything I want to make across the top of a piece of paper, then work backwards from the time I want to serve (about 4 PM - I try to serve dinner at the end of the early football game). I write this plan up the weekend before Thanksgiving, before I make my grocery list. That way I don’t forget anything at the store. (OK, I’ll still forget something, but it cuts down on the last-minute trips to get, say, another pound of butter, or the package of fresh sage leaves.) You’d think I’d have this plan saved somewhere, but I write it up from scratch every year. I’m doing it now for this newsletter, so I’m ahead of the game this year. (And, since I’m putting it in the newsletter, I’ll actually have it saved to use next year.) Make it AheadThe only things I cook entirely on Thanksgiving are the turkey, mashed potatoes, and stuffing. I haven’t found make-ahead recipes for the mashed potatoes and stuffing that I like. I do prep the stuffing the night before, so it is partially cooked - it just needs to go in the oven. And reheating a tray of turkey the next day just doesn’t work for me on Thanksgiving. Oh, and I have to chop up the salad - but the dressing is also made the night before. Everything else I prep and cook earlier in the week, so all I have to do is reheat it and serve. Sweet potatoes, gravy, green beans, cranberry sauce, all the baking - they are all ready to go on the big day. The MenuHere’s what I’m going to make this year:
How do I get all that on the table? The 4 P’s - Planning Prevents Poor Performance. So, here’s the plan - my countdown to T-Day: The Countdown to T-DayI think of Thanksgiving week as a countdown to liftoff at 4PM on Thursday. Apologies to NASA and my favorite movie of all time. Monday - T-3 days and countingDry brine the turkeys - rub with salt and spices and refrigerate, covered in plastic wrap Make a batch of turkey broth with the neck and giblets from the turkeys - for gravy and stuffing Tuesday - T-2 days and countingBaking day (this day is all about my wife, the baker in the family - she’s making pies and dinner rolls) Make the cranberry sauce and refrigerate Make the sweet potatoes and spread into a large baking dish Wednesday - T-1 day and countingAssemble the stuffing and refrigerate it for baking on T-Day Make the gravy and refrigerate Par-cook the green beans and refrigerate Remove plastic wrap from dry brining turkeys to let the skin dry before cooking Make salad dressing Thursday - it’s go time!T-5 hours and counting (1100)Remove turkeys from refrigerator to take the chill off - except for ice bags on the breasts Truss and spit the turkeys (if using rotisserie, which I am) T-4.5 hours and counting (1130)Start grills - start charcoal for charcoal grill, preheat gas grill T-4 hours (1200)Turkeys on the grill (and rotisserie) Chop vegetables and lettuce for salad, put in refrigerator T-3 hours (1300)Add charcoal to grill Peel and dice the potatoes, cover with water, leave on the counter Welcome guests as they start to arrive Watch the start of the early football game Have a tasty beverage to fortify myself for the afternoon’s work T-2 hours (1400)Add charcoal to grill Mingle and chat with guests, watch some of the early football game Start simmering the mashed potatoes T-90 minutes (1430)Stuffing into oven to cook Mash potatoes, leave on stovetop to keep warm T-60 minutes (1500)Turkeys done, off of grill, onto counter and cover with foil Sprinkle brown sugar on sweet potatoes, into oven to reheat Remove foil from stuffing pan to crisp up the top T-45 minutesGravy onto stovetop to reheat Green beans onto stovetop to finish T-30 minutesStuffing done, out of oven and onto counter Turkey carving (takes about 20 minutes) Rolls into oven to reheat T-15 minutesPour some gravy into gravy boats for the tables (adults table and “kids” table) Rolls into bowls on tables Dress and toss the salad Set up buffet table with everything else T-0 - Liftoff!Ring the dinner bell, it’s time to grab a plate and fill it up! (I want a drumstick.) Tips and TricksSome other tips that didn’t fit in above: Give the turkey some buffer timeMy experience is that the turkey has the most variable cooking time. I cook 12(ish) pound turkeys, which take about 3 hours - but I’ve had a turkey finish in 2 hours, and other ones finish closer to 4 hours. That’s why I aim for my turkeys to be done an hour ahead of time - they can rest if they’re early, covered with foil to keep them warm. And, if they take longer than expected, I’ve got extra time in the schedule. Use the grill as a backup ovenI grill my turkeys, and not just because they taste better that way. Grilling frees up the oven for the side dishes, and gets the turkeys out of the crowded kitchen. If you use the grill, the Thermoworks Smoke probe thermometer is my favorite for watching the temperature while I'm in the house. (It's the thermometer in the picture of a turkey on the grill up above.) It has multiple probes - I use one in the turkey, and another on the grill grate to track the grill temperature. The reason I love it is the long range RF wireless receiver. It never loses the signal from the base unit, no matter where I am in the house. I hang the receiver around my neck and go about my other cooking, and whenever I need to, I can check the turkey and grill temperatures. (I'm a Thermoworks affiliate, so if you use the link, I'll get a small commission at no extra charge to you. I bought my Smoke thermometer with my own money, and have been using it for over a decade of Thanksgivings, so I can recommend it without any reservations.) Guests who ask “if you need any help”The goal is to say “Everything is fine, go enjoy yourself.” Now, for some guests, this should be the answer even if everything is NOT fine. They’re just trying to be polite. (Or will be more trouble than they’re worth when they’re “helping.” Not that I have that problem with anyone in my extended family - they’re all actually trying to help.) But, if it’s crunch time, and you really do need help, don’t be too proud to ask for it. Have a few things picked out ahead of time that you can pass off easily - Can you mash the potatoes for me? Hold the platter while I lift the turkeys off of the grill? Toss the salad? Move things to the buffet table while I carve? Guests who want to bring somethingEvery family has dishes that make Thanksgiving complete. If you have a specialist in the family, someone who makes the best mashed potatoes/sweet potatoes/butternut squash/salad/pie/whatever, ask them to bring it. Especially if it’s something they can make ahead. (Make room for it in the oven in your schedule, or scoot over in the kitchen so they have some counter space.) Or, ask them to bring snacks, appetizers, drinks, or dessert. (I usually ask people to bring snacks/appetizers, to give everyone something to munch on while dinner is cooking.) Once I have everything I need, my default response is to say “just bring yourself!” Serve Buffet StyleInstead of passing everything around at the table, one plate at a time, I find it easier to put it all on my kitchen island, tell everyone to bring their plates, and then let everyone filter in and out of the dining room when they need seconds. (We’re not that formal at the dining table - can you tell?) Use the great outdoors as a refrigeratorI live in Northeast Ohio, so most Thanksgivings are cold enough for the table on my deck to double as a backyard refrigerator. I pull the table right next to my sliding door so I can stack food on it to cool down overnight. Of course, if you have critters in your neighborhood, this might not work. Make sure you have solid lids on anything you put out. The metal lids for my pots have worked for me, but I don’t get much wildlife beyond birds and squirrels out here in the suburbs. (The one time critters got into the food was when we left a plastic-wrapped plate of cookies out.) Keep the chef lubricatedNow this step is optional, but…I find that the day goes much smoother if cooking is accompanied by a glass of wine. Or a bottle of beer while I hang out next to the grill, “checking on the progress of the turkey.” What do you think?Do you have this precise of a plan, or am I being persnickety? What are your favorite make-ahead Thanksgiving sides? Any family “must haves” for the Thanksgiving table? Write me and let me know. Also … what did I forget? I always have a nagging feeling that I forgot something for Thanksgiving dinner. Writing this is giving me that feeling a month early. (If I did forget something, I’m sure I’ll remember it is right after I send this email.) What about Thanksgiving Recipes?I have a set of three emails with Thanksgiving recipes scheduled for the week before Thanksgiving:
Expect those in your Inbox starting on November 16th. If you can’t wait, here is a link to my Thanksgiving Recipes Index. Shameless Self-PromotionDid you know I wrote a set of Rotisserie Grilling cookbooks? And that I have a Rotisserie Turkey Cookbook to help with your turkey on Thanksgiving? Check it out if you’re interested in giving the big bird a spin on your grill. It's Not Your Time Yet!My favorite Thanksgiving cartoon... October Posts RoundupFall finally arrived! We’ve had two weeks of crisp, clear fall weather here in Northeast Ohio, and I’m leaning into my cold-weather comfort cooking. Instant Pot German Pot RoastI updated one of my old favorites - a German-style pork pot roast slathered in mustard. I was lucky enough to travel to Germany last summer, and this recipe has gone into regular rotation ever since I got back, reminding me of my days on the Rhine. Recipe: Instant Pot German Pot Roast with Mustard (Senfbraten) Instant Pot Chicken Pho (Phở Gà)I love turning a rotisserie chicken into a soup using homemade broth. Chris Young’s $6 Michelin Stock in 60 Minutes takes my basic technique and adds a lot of great finesse steps to improve the flavor (rip the chicken into shreds, thin-slice the aromatics and sauté them, to increase the surface area of everything and maximize extraction). After watching the video, I had to make some soup, and since Vietnamese Pho is one of my favorites, I started testing Chicken Pho from a rotisserie chicken. Recipe: Instant Pot Chicken Pho (Vietnamese Phở Gà) from a Rotisserie Chicken Instant Pot Pork Shoulder and White Bean Stew (Tuscan Pork and Beans)I love my Rancho Gordo bean boxes, but I’m falling behind. I still have bags of beans from earlier boxes, and the new one is on the way. This recipe used up some of my bean backlog, and turned into a fantastic stew. Recipe: Instant Pot Pork Shoulder and White Bean Stew (Tuscan Pork and Beans) Instant Pot Black-Eyed PeasSpeaking of using up my bean backlog - I updated one of my most popular New Year’s Day recipes, black-eyed peas for luck in the new year. (Yes, I know it’s only October. Black-eyed peas are good any time of year.) Recipe: Instant Pot Black-Eyed Peas (No Soaking) Q&A: Crock Pot instead of Pressure Cooker?Need to use my crock pot [for the Instant Pot German Pot Roast recipe]?????? Reader Joseph I get this question a lot, and the answer is pretty simple. Here is how I move a recipe from a pressure cooker to a slow cooker. You’ll need a slow cooker (of course) and a 12-inch frypan. Then, make the following changes to the recipe:
…and that’s it. Simple, right? Also, those slow cooking times are minimums. I think of 6 hours as 6 to 8 hours, and 8 hours as 8-10 hours. You have some buffer if you overshoot that cooking time. Also, I own both a slow cooker (Crock Pot) and a pressure cooker (Instant Pot) - multi-pots like the Instant Pot are great at pressure cooking, but they’re not good slow cookers. (One of my most-commented-on posts is Instant Pot as a Slow Cooker?, where LOTS of people want to complain after trying the slow cook function on their Instant Pot.) Thanks for reading!That’s it for this month. Questions, comments, and ideas are welcome - drop me a line. Thanks again, good luck with your Thanksgiving dinner, and see you next month! Mike Vrobel - DadCooksDinner.com November 6, 2026 |
I’m an enthusiastic home cook who writes about pressure cooking, rotisserie grilling, sous vide, and any other food topics that grab my attention. Subscribe to get recipes, technique deep-dives, and a look at what’s cooking in my kitchen.
Thanksgiving Turkey, the DadCooksDinner way It’s Thanksgiving Planning Week, and I have a LOT of Thanksgiving-related posts to share. This week, I’m sending out emails with Thanksgiving recipes and suggestions. Today is email 1 of 3, all about Thanksgiving turkey. If you’re looking for something specific, check out my Thanksgiving Recipes page. I always grill my turkey on Thanksgiving. Grilled turkey tastes better and frees the oven up for side dishes. I use my pressure cooker for prep work,...
Fall is finally here! Fall is my favorite season - I love a touch of cold in the air, the colors in the leaves, and that it’s soup season! Speaking of soup, let’s talk about it’s key ingredient, broth… An Ode to Pressure Cooker Chicken Broth “Stock. Stock is the backbone of good cooking. You (home chefs) need it and you don’t have it. I have the luxury of 30-quart stockpots, a willing prep crew, readily available bones and plenty of refrigeration space. Does this mean you should subject your...
Things I Love: A Kitchen Scale I can’t live without a kitchen scale. It’s an essential measuring tool in my kitchen - not used as much as my measuring spoons or measuring cups, but up there with my instant read thermometer for usefulness. Now, when I say that I can’t live without a kitchen scale, I should say we cannot live without a kitchen scale. I use it a lot for measuring ingredients, especially when I’m developing recipes. But my wife depends on it. She uses the scale every day to weigh...